基于矿柱失稳风险分析的采空区关键矿柱重定义与辨识

doi:10.13722/j.cnki.jrme.2023.0884

Abstract
Figure/Table
References (0)
Related Citation (15)

Download: PDF (1435 KB) HTML (1 KB)
Export: BibTeX | EndNote (RIS)

Abstract The large-scale collapse of goaf is one of the typical disasters in underground mines. This disaster is primarily triggered by the instability of the critical key pillar within the goaf. In this paper，to accurately identify the critical pillar in the goaf，the fundamental concept of the critical pillar in goaf is developed based on the cascading failure mechanism of pillar group in goaf and the principles of risk theory. Additionally，a novel method for recognizing the critical pillar is proposed based on a comprehensive risk analysis of pillar instability. The methodology involves several key steps：(1) obtaining the distribution characteristics of pillar strength through field research or empirical estimations，and then establishing the probability density function for pillar strength within the goaf；(2) computing the stress on each pillar by introducing the formula of maximum stress diffusion distance，subsequently，calculating the instability probability for each pillar；(3) utilizing a dynamic updating iterative approach to assess the stress transfer and instability patterns within the pillar group system，considering any pillar as the initial failure point；(4) quantitatively characterizing the consequence of any single pillar instability by using the index of the bearing area loss rate of the pillar group within the goaf，specifically measuring the severity of goaf collapse disasters induced by individual pillar instability；(5) determining the instability risk value for each pillar by calculating the product of the instability probability and its associated consequence. Accordingly，identifying the critical pillar within the goaf as the one with the highest instability risk value. The proposed method is applied to Fetr6 mining area for verification. The results demonstrate that this method is easy to implement，involving straightforward parameter acquisition and calculation processes，while also offering clear physical significance. Furthermore，it proves to be more scientifically and logically sound than the traditional safety factor method. Thus，this method holds promise for wide-ranging applications in practical engineering scenarios.

Key words： mining engineering goaf underground pillar group cascading failure critical pillar instability probability disaster consequence risk assessment

	Service

	E-mail this article
	Add to my bookshelf
	Add to citation manager
	E-mail Alert
	RSS
	Articles by authors
	CAI Xin1
	2
	HUANG Yashuai1
	ZHOU Zilong1
	YUAN Jifeng1
	ZANG Haizhi1
	CHEN Lu1
	HUANG Yinghua1
	3
	FU Jun4
	WANG Yunmin2

Cite this article:

CAI Xin1,2,HUANG Yashuai1, et al. Redefinition and identification of critical pillars in goaf based on the risk analysis of pillar instability[J]. , 2024, 43(1): 216-225.

URL:

https://rockmech.whrsm.ac.cn/EN/10.13722/j.cnki.jrme.2023.0884 OR https://rockmech.whrsm.ac.cn/EN/Y2024/V43/I1/216

[1] 李夕兵，李地元，赵国彦，等. 金属矿地下采空区探测、处理与安全评判[J]. 采矿与安全工程学报，2006，(1)：24–29.(LI Xibing，LI Diyuan，ZHAO Guoyan. Detecting，disposal and safety evaluation of the underground goaf in metal mines[J]. Journal of Mining and Safety Engineering，2006，(1)：24–29.(in Chinese))
[2] 朱万成，董航宇，刘溪鸽，等. 金属矿山多矿柱承载与失稳破坏研究[J]. 采矿与岩层控制工程学报，2022，4(4)：043037.(ZHU Wancheng，DONG Hangyu，LIU Xige，et al. Review of bearing and instability of multi-pillar in metal mines[J]. Journal of Mining and Strata Control Engineering，2022，4(4)：043037.(in Chinese))
[3] 王啟明，徐必根，唐绍辉，等. 我国金属非金属矿山采空区现状与治理对策分析[J]. 矿业研究与开发，2009，29(4)：63–68.(WU Qiming，XU Bigen，TANG Shaohui，et al. The actual state of mined-out areas in metallic and nonmetallic mines and the countermeasures for the treatment of the mined-out areas in China[J]. Mining Research and Development，2009，29(4)：63–68.(in Chinese))
[4] 童立元，刘松玉，邱钰，等. 高速公路下伏采空区问题国内外研究现状及进展[J]. 岩石力学与工程学报，2004，23(7)：1 198–1 202. (TONG Liyuan，LIU Songyu，QIU Jue，et al. Current research state of problems associated with mined-out regions under expressway and future development[J]. Chinese Journal of Rock Mechanics and Engineering，2004，23(7)：1 198–1 202.(in Chinese))
[5] 山东省安全生产监督管理局. 临沂市平邑县万庄石膏矿区“12•25”采空区重大坍塌事故调查报告[R]. 济南：山东省应急管理厅，2016. (Shandong Provincial Safety Supervision Bureau. Investigation report of “12•25” major goaf collapse accident in Wanzhuang Gypsum mining area，Pingyi County，Linyi City[R]. Jinan：Department of Emergency Management of Shandong Province，2016.(in Chinese))
[6] 国务院安全生产委员会. 金属非金属地下矿山采空区事故隐患治理工作方案[R]. 北京：国务院安委会，2016.(Work Safety Commission of the State Council. Workplan for controlling hidden danger of goaf accidents in metal and non-metal underground mines[R]. Beijing：Work Safety Commission of the State Council，2016.(in Chinese))
[7] 黄英华，徐必根，唐绍辉. 房柱法开采矿山采空区失稳模式及机制[J]. 矿业研究与开发，2009，29(4)：24–26.(HUANG Yinghua，XU Bigen，TANG Shaohui. Study on the damage patterns and mechanism of mined-out area in mines using room-and-pillar mining method[J]. Mining Research and Development，2009，29(4)：24–26.(in Chinese))
[8] 刘沐宇，徐长佑. 地下采空区矿柱稳定性分析[J]. 矿冶工程，2000，(1)：19–22.(LIU Muyu，XU Changyou. Stability analysis of pillars in minedout area[J]. Mining and Metallurgical Engineering，2000，(1)：19–22.(in Chinese))
[9] 刘敦文，古德生，徐国元. 地下矿山采空区处理方法的评价与优选[J]. 中国矿业，2004，(8)：54–57.(LIU Dunwen，GU Desheng，XU Guoyuan. Evaluation and optimization of disposal methods for gob in underground mine[J]. China Mining Magazine，2004，(8)：54–57.(in Chinese))
[10] POULSEN B A，SHEN B，WILLIAMS D J，et al. Strength reduction on saturation of coal and coal measures rocks with implications for coal pillar strength[J]. International Journal of Rock Mechanics and Mining Sciences，2014，71：41–52.
[11] BERTUZZI R，DOUGLAS K，MOSTYN G. An approach to model the strength of coal pillars[J]. International Journal of Rock Mechanics and Mining Sciences，2016，89：165–175.
[12] SAIN STEPHAN R. The nature of statistical learning theory[J]. Technometrics，1997，38(4)：409.
[13] ZHOU J，LI X B，SHI X Z，et al. Predicting pillar stability for underground mine using Fisher discriminant analysis and SVM methods[J]. Transactions of Nonferrous Metals Society of China，2011，21：2 734–2 743.
[14] TAWADROUS A S，KATSABANIS P D. Prediction of surface crown pillar stability using artificial neural networks[J]. International Journal for Numerical and Analytical Methods in Geomechanics，2007，31(7)：917–931.
[15] 赵国彦，刘建，周健. 基于不同判别准则的硬岩矿柱状态识别模型[J]. 中南大学学报：自然科学版，2018，49(11)：2 813–2 820. (ZHAO Guoyan，LIU Jian，ZHOU Jian. Recognition model of hard rock pillars state based on different discriminant criterions[J]. Journal of Central South University：Science and Technology，2018，49(11)：2 813–2 820.(in Chinese))
[16] 周子龙，陈璐，赵源，等. 双矿柱体系变形破坏及承载特性的试验研究[J]. 岩石力学与工程学报，2017，36(2)：420–428.(ZHOU Zilong，CHEN Lu，ZHAO Yuan，et al. Experimental study on failure mechanism and bearing characteristic of double-pillar system[J]. Chinese Journal of Rock Mechanics and Engineering，2017，36(2)：420–428.(in Chinese))
[17] ZHOU Z L，CHEN L，CAI X，et al. Experimental investigation of the progressive failure of multiple pillar-roof system[J]. Rock Mechanics and Rock Engineering，2018，51(5)：1 629–1 636.
[18] 周子龙，李夕兵，赵国彦. 民窿空区群级联失稳评价[J]. 自然灾害学报，2007，16(5)：91–95.(ZHOU Zilong，LI Xibing，ZHAO Guoyan. Evaluation of cascading collapse for private mined zone groups[J]. Journal of Natural Disasters，2007，16(5)：91–95.(in Chinese))
[19] 王金安，李大钟，马海涛. 采空区矿柱–顶板体系流变力学模型研究[J]. 岩石力学与工程学报，2010，29(3)：577–582.(WANG Jin?an，LI Dazhong，MA Haitao. Study of rheological mechanical model of pillar-roof system in mined-out area[J]. Chinese Journal of Rock Mechanics and Engineering，2010，29(3)：577–582.(in Chinese))
[20] DEHGHAN S，SHAHRIAR K，MAAREFVAND P，et al. 3-D numerical modelling of domino failure of hard rock pillars in Fetr6 Chromite Mine，lran，and comparison with empirical methodslJl. Journal of Central South University，2013，20(2)：541–549.
[21] 马海涛，谢芳. 大规模采空区渐进式矿柱坍塌的简化模拟[J]. 中国安全生产科学技术，2013，9(8)：17–21.(MA Haitao，XIE Fang. Simplified simulation on cascading pillar failure in large-scale goaf[J]. Journal of Safety Science and Technology，2013，9(8)：17–21.(in Chinese))
[22] 丘帆，马海涛，欧阳明，等. 基于Voronoi图和时间效应的矿柱失稳预测[J]. 中国安全生产科学技术，2014，10(2)：38–43.(QIU Fan，MA Haitao，OUYANG Ming ，et al. Prediction of pillar instability based on Voronoi chart and time effect[J]. Journal of Safety Science and Technology，2014，10(2)：38–43.(in Chinese))
[23] 冯国瑞，白锦文，史旭东，等. 遗留煤柱群链式失稳的关键柱理论及其应用展望[J]. 煤炭学报，2021，46(1)：164–179.(FENG Guorui，BAI Jinwen，SHI Xudong，et al. Key pillar theory in the chain failure of residual coal pillars and its application prospect[J]. Journal of China Coal Society，2021，46(1)：164–179.(in Chinese))
[24] 白锦文，宋诚，王红伟，等. 遗留群柱中关键柱判别方法与软件[J]. 煤炭学报，2022，47(2)：651–661.(BAI Jinwen，SONG Cheng，WANG Hongwei，et al. Identification method and software of key pillar in the residual pillar system[J]. Journal of China Coal Society，2022，47(2)：651–661.(in Chinese))
[25] 殷杰，尹占娥，许世远，等. 灾害风险理论与风险管理方法研究[J]. 灾害学，2009，24(2)：7–11.(YING Jie，YIN Zhan?e，XU Shiyuan，et al. Disaster Risk theory and risk management method[J]. Journal of Catastrophology，2009，24(2)：7–11.(in Chinese))
[26] GALVIN JM. Coal pillar strength determinations for Australian and Sout African mining condition[C]// Proceedings of Second International Workshop or Coal Pillar Mechanics and Design. Colombia：DHHS(NIOSH) Publication，1999：63–70.
[27] MARINO G G，BAUER R A. Behavior of abandoned room and pillar in Illinois[J]. Geotechnical and Geological Engineering，1989，7(4)：271–281.
[28] KOUSICK B. A unique approach to determine the time-dependent in-sit strength of coal pillars[C]// Proceedings of Second International Workshop on Coa Pillar Mechanics and Design. Colombia：DHHS(NIOSH) Publication，1999：5–8.
[29] ZIPF R K. Simulation of cascading pillar failure in room-and-pillar mines using boundary-element-method[C]// Proceedings of 2nd North American Rock Mechanics Symposium. Montreal，Canada：[s. n.]，1996：1 887–1 892.
[30] ESTERHUIZEN E，MARK C，MURPHY M M. The ground response curve，pillar loading and pillar failure in coal mines[C]// Proceedings of International Conference on Ground Control in Mining. [S. l.]：[s. n.]，2010：19–27.
[31] 马海涛. 矿山采空区灾害风险分级与失稳预警方法[博士学位论文][D]. 北京：北京科技大学，2015.(MA Haitao. Study on method of risk classification and instability forecasting of goaf[Ph. D. Thesis][D]. Beijing：University of Science and Technology Beijing，2015.(in Chinese))
[32] ABEL J. Soft rock pillars[J]. International Journal of Mining and Geological Engineering，1988，6：215–248.
[33] HUANG J S，KELLY R，LI D Q，et al. Updating reliability of single piles and pile groups by load tests[J]. Computers and Geotechnics，2016，73：221–230.
[34] 臧海智. 废弃采空区矿柱群的可靠性及连续倒塌风险评估[硕士学位论文][D]. 长沙：中南大学，2020.(ZANG Haizhi. Reliability analysis and risk assessment for the progressive failure of pillar sections in abandoned goaf[M. S. Thesis][D]. Changsha：Central South University，2020.(in Chinese))
[35] ZHOU Z L，ZANG H Z，CAO W Z，et al. Risk assessment for the cascading failure of underground pillar sections considering interaction between pillars[J]. International Journal of Rock Mechanics and Mining Sciences，2019，124：104142.
[36] FARYAB Company Ltd. Fetr-6 underground mine design，technical report[R]. [S. l.]：[s. n.]，2008.