简化增量法计算土钉轴力的模型准确性分析

doi:10.13722/j.cnki.jrme.2020.0306

Abstract
Figure/Table
References (0)
Related Citation (15)

Download: PDF (8794 KB) HTML (1 KB)
Export: BibTeX | EndNote (RIS)

Abstract Although the Rankine-based simplified incremental calculation method(SICM) has been widely applied in practice for prediction of nail loads，its model accuracy has not yet fully assessed. In this paper，a large database containing a total of 466 measured nail loads from 178 nails reported in the literature was established. After removing questionable data，the remaining load data from 143 nails were used to evaluate the accuracy of the Rankine SICM，which is characterized by the model bias defined as the ratio of measured to predicted nail loads，and the influence of 3 working conditions on the accuracy of the SICM was also investigated. The results show that，under typical cases，the current Rankine SICM underestimates averagely the maximum nail load by about 10% to 17% with a high prediction dispersion over 90% while overestimates the mean nail load by about 15% with a moderate prediction dispersion of about 70%. In addition，the accuracy is statistically correlated to the magnitude of the predicted value，which is undesirable. It was proposed to estimate the nail load based on the Coulomb active earth pressure theory instead of the Rankine theory for accuracy improvement. A calibration constant of about 0.75 is introduced to calibrate the computed nail load. The Coulomb SICM was demonstrated to be unbiased on average with a medium prediction dispersion from 44% to 66%. It is also shown that the accuracies of both Rankine and Coulomb SICMs are significantly influenced by soil types whereas the influence of load allocation schemes，external loading conditions and wall types is marginal. The model biases of Rankine and Coulomb SICMs respectively follow lognormal and Weibull distributions. Finally，the accuracies of the two types of SICM were discussed complementally from another four angles.

Key words： soil mechanics soil nail wall nail load simplified incremental calculation method model uncertainty reliability-based design

	Service

	E-mail this article
	Add to my bookshelf
	Add to citation manager
	E-mail Alert
	RSS
	Articles by authors
	QUE Yun1
	HUANG Rui1
	LIN Peiyuan2
	3
	YANG Guanghua4

Cite this article:

QUE Yun1,HUANG Rui1,LIN Peiyuan2, et al. Characterization of model accuracy in prediction of soil nail loads using simplified incremental calculation method[J]. , 2021, 40(1): 158-174.

URL:

https://rockmech.whrsm.ac.cn/EN/10.13722/j.cnki.jrme.2020.0306 OR https://rockmech.whrsm.ac.cn/EN/Y2021/V40/I1/158

[1] 刘国彬，侯学渊，黄院雄. 城市基坑工程发展的几点看法[C]// 中国土木工程学会土力学及岩土工程学术会议. [S. l.]：[s. n.]，1999.(LIU Guobin，HOU Xueyuan，HUANG Yuanxiong. Several views on the development of urban foundation pit engineering[C]// Academic Conference on Geomechanics and Geotechnical Engineering，Chinese Society of Civil Engineering. [S. l.]：[s. n.]，1999.(in Chinese))
[2] 齐锡晶，韩新刚，邓李杰. 沈阳地下空间开发的霍尔三维研究[J]. 地下空间与工程学报，2018，14(3)：573–578.(QI Xijing，HAN Xingang，DENG Lijie. Hall three-dimensional research on underground space development[J]. Chinese Journal of Underground Space and Engineering，2018，14(3)，573–578.(in Chinese))
[3] YUAN J，LIN P Y，HUANG R，et al. Statistical evaluation and calibration of two methods for predicting nail loads of soil nail walls in China[J]. Computers and Geotechnics，2019，108(4)：269–279.
[4] YUAN J，LIN P Y. Reliability analysis of soil nail internal limit states using default FHWA load and resistance models[J]. Marine Georesources and Geotechnology，2019，37(7)：783–800.
[5] 边培松. 深基坑土钉锚杆支护体系变形性状研究[硕士学位论文][D]. 济南：山东大学，2011.(BIAN Peisong. Research on the deformation performance of composite bracing technique of soil anchors and soil nails for deep foundation excavation[M. S. Thesis][D]. Jinan：Shandong University，2011.(in Chinese))
[6] 吴静. 深基坑超前钢管桩复合预应力锚杆支护数值模拟研究[硕士学位论文][D]. 武汉：中国地质大学，2009.(WU Jing. Numerical simulation research on prestressed anchor support with advanced steel pipe pile in deep foundation pit[M. S. Thesis][D]. Wuhan：China University of Geosciences，2009.(in Chinese))
[7] 段立平. 土钉支护结构钉土相互作用机理研究[硕士学位论文][D]. 湘潭：湘潭大学，2010.(DUAN Liping. The study of the mechanism of nail soil interaction in soil nailing structures[M. S. Thesis][D]. Xiangtan：Xiangtan University，2010.(in Chinese))
[8] LAZARTE C A，ELIAS V，ESPINOZA D，et al. Geotechnical engineering circular No.7 soil nail walls[R]. Washington，D C：Federal Highway Administration，2003.
[9] LAZARTE C A，ROBINSON H，GÓMEZ J E，et al. Geotechnical engineering circular No.7 soil nail walls—reference manual[R]. Washington，D C：Federal Highway Administration，2015.
[10] 河上房羲. 工程上力学计算题详解[M]. 赵焕斌译. 黑龙江：黑龙江科学技术出版社，1987.(Heshang Fangxi. Detailed explanation of mechanical calculation problems in engineering[M]. Translated by ZHAO Huanbin. Heilongjiang：Heilongjiang Science and Technology Publishing House，1987.(in Chinese))
[11] 中华人民共和国行业标准编写组. JGJ 120—2012建筑基坑支护技术规程[S]. 北京：中国建筑工业出版社，1999.(The Professional Standard Compilation Groups of the People's Republic of China. JGJ 120—2012 Technical regulations for foundation pit support[S]. Beijing：China Construction Industry Publishing House，1999.(in Chinese))
[12] 中华人民共和国行业标准编写组. CECS96：97 基坑土钉支护技术规程[S]. 北京：中国城市出版社，1997.(The Professional Standard Compilation Groups of the People's Republic of China. CECS96：97 Technical specification for soil nailing support of foundation pit[S]. Beijing：China City Press，1997.(in Chinese))
[13] PHEAR A，DEW C，OZSOY B，et al. Soil nailing-best practice guidance[R]. London：Report No. CIRIA C637，2005.
[14] JURAN I，ELIAS V. Soil nailed retaining structures：Analysis of case histories[C]// A Ten Year Update of Soil Improvement Techniques. Geosynthetics for Soil Improvement. New York：Geotechnical Special Publication，1987：232–244.
[15] JURAN I，BAUDRAND G，FARRAG K，et al. Kinematical limit analysis for design of soil-nailed structures[J]. Journal of Geotechnical Engineering，1990，116(1)：54–72.
[16] WENTWORTH T D. Distribution of axial forces in soil nails based on interpretation of measured strains[Ph. D. Thesis][D]. Seattle：University of Washington，1994.
[17] BANERJEE S，FINNEY A，WENTWORTH T，et al. Evaluation of design methodologies for soil-nailed walls，Volume 1[R]. Washington D C：TRAC，1998.
[18] BANERJEE S，FINNEY A，WENTWORTH T，et al. Evaluation of design methodologies for soil-nailed walls，Volume 2：distribution of axial forces in soil nails based on interpretation of measured strains[R]. Washington D C：TRAC，1998.
[19] 杨光华，黄宏伟. 基坑支护土钉力的简化增量计算法[J]. 岩土力学，2004，25(1)：15–19.(YANG Guanghua，HUANG Hongwei. Simplified incremental calculation method of soil nail forces for retaining and protection of foundation pits[J]. Rock and Soil Mechanics，2004，25(1)：15–19.( in Chinese))
[20] 张钦喜，何建勇，霍达. 土钉内力计算方法的探讨与实例分析[J]. 北京工业大学学报，2002，28(4)：448–451.(ZHANG Qinxi，HE Jianyong，HUO Da. Calculation of the interior force of soil nails and case analysis[J]. Journal of Beijing Polytechnic University，2002，28(4)：448–451.(in Chinese))
[21] HU Y，LIN P. Probabilistic prediction of maximum tensile loads in soil nails[J]. Advances in Civil Engineering，2018，DOI：https：//doi.org/10.1155/2018/3410146.
[22] LIN P，BATHURST R J，LIU J. Statistical evaluation of the FHWA simplified method and modifications for predicting soil nail loads[J]. Journal of Geotechnical and Geoenvironmental Engineering，2017，143(3)：04016107.
[23] PHOON K K，KULHAWY F. Characterisation of model uncertainties for laterally loaded rigid drilled shafts[J]. Geotechnique，2005，55(1)：45–54.
[24] TANG C，PHOON K K. Statistics of model factors and consideration in reliability-based design of axially loaded helical piles[J]. Journal of Geotechnical and Geoenvironmental Engineering，2018，144(8)：04018050.
[25] TANG C，PHOON K K. Characterization of model uncertainty in predicting axial resistance of piles driven into clay[J]. Canadian Geotechnical Journal，2018，DOI：https：//doi.org/10.1139/cgj-2018–0386.
[26] TANG C，PHOON K K. Statistics of model factors in reliability-based design of axially loaded driven piles in sand[J]. Canadian Geotechnical Journal，2018，55(11)：1 592–1 610.
[27] MIYATA Y，BATHURST R J. Statistical assessment of load model accuracy for steel grid-reinforced soil walls[J]. Acta Geotechnica，14(2)：57–70.
[28] 梅迪. 基于增量法的土钉支护结构变形计算及分析[硕士学位论文][D]. 兰州：兰州理工大学，2011.(MEI Di. The calculation and analysis of deformation of soil nailing retaining structure based on the incremental method[M. S. Thesis][D]. Lanzhou：Lanzhou University of Technology，2011.(in Chinese))
[29] 李成昌，肖明贵，卢林斌. 简化增量计算法在土钉支护基坑中的应用研究[J]. 路基工程，2009，26(5)：42–44.(LI Chengchang，XIAO Minggui，LU Linbin. Application of simplified incremental method in soil nail supporting foundation pit[J]. Subgrade Engineering，2009，26(5)：42–44.(in Chinese))
[30] 王辉，郭院成，朱翔. 基于增量法的预应力锚杆复合土钉支护体系的设计计算[J]. 公路工程，2016，41(1)：108–111.(WANG Hui，GUO Yuancheng，ZHU Xiang. Design calculation on soil nail-pre-stressed anchor composite retaining system based on incremental method[J]. Highway Engineering，2016，41(1)：108–111.(in Chinese))
[31] 杨光华，陆培炎. 深基坑开挖中多支撑或多锚式地下连续墙的增量计算法[J]. 建筑结构，1994，23(8)：28–31.(YANG Guanghua，LU Peiyan. Incremental calculation method of multi-support or multi-anchor diaphragm wall in deep foundation pit excavation[J]. Building Structure，1994，23(8)：28–31.(in Chinese))
[32] 杨光华，深基坑开挖中多支撑支护结构的土压力问题[J]. 岩土工程学报，1998，20(6)：113–115.(YANG Gaunghua. The earth pressure problems for the multi-braced retaining structure of deep excavation[J]. Chinese Journal of Geotechnical Engineering，1998，20(6)：113–115.(in Chinese))
[33] 杨光华. 土钉支护中土钉力和位移的计算问题[J]. 岩土力学，2012，33(1)：137–146.(YANG Guanghua. The earth pressure problems for the multi-braced retaining structure of deep excavation[J]. Chinese Journal of Geotechnical Engineering，2012，33(1)：137–146.(in Chinese))
[34] 李思平，周辉，李川. 基坑水平位移与土钉拉力的现场测试分析[J]. 岩土工程技术，2003，17(5)：305–311.(LI Siping，ZHOU Hui，LI Chuan. In-situ test analysis for the horizontal displacement and the soil nailing tension of a foundation pit[J]. Geotechnical Engineering Technique，2003，17(5)：305–311.(in Chinese))
[35] 张建龙，何家柱. 基坑土钉支护结构受力及变形分析[J]. 工程勘察，2003，30(2)：39–41.(ZHANG Jianlong，HE Jiazhu. Stress and deformation analysis of soil nailing retaining structure in foundation pit[J]. Geotechnical Investigation Surveying，2003，30(2)：39–41.(in Chinese))
[36] 张明聚，郭忠贤. 土钉支护工作性能的现场测试研究[J]. 岩土工程学报，2001，23(3)：319–323.(ZHANG Mingju，GUO Zhongxian. Research on behaviors of soil nailing by field test. Chinese Journal of Geotechnical Engineering，2001，23(3)：319–323.(in Chinese))
[37] 段启伟. 土钉支护现场实测与数值模拟[硕士学位论文][D]. 北京：北京交通大学，2007.(DUAN Qiwei. Field measurement and numerical simulation of soil nailing[M. S. Thesis][D]. Beijing：Beijing Jiaotong University，2007.(in Chinese))
[38] 张钦喜，秦汉坤，佟德凯，等. 朝外SOHO土钉拉力现场监测研究[J]. 北京工业大学学报，2007，33(5)：507–511.(ZHANG Qinxi，QIN Hankun， TONG Dekai，et al. Measurements and analysis of stress in soil nails of Chaowai SOHO project[J]. Beijing University of Technology，2007，33(5)：507–511.(in Chinese))
[39] 张钦喜，陈鹏，尹文彪. 国贸中心三期基坑支护工程监测研究[J]. 岩石力学与工程学报，2012，31(11)：2 319–2 326.(ZHANG Qinxi，CHEN Peng，YIN Wenbiao. Monitoring and study for support engineering of deep excavation of china world trade centre tower phase 3[J]. Chinese Journal of Rock Mechanics and Engineering，2012，31(11)：2 319–2 326.(in Chinese))
[40] 张钦喜，段勇刚，李继红，等. CNC科研中心办公楼土钉拉力现场监测研究[J]. 岩土工程学报，2010，32(增2)：545–549.(ZHANG Qinxi， DUAN Yonggang，Li Hongji et al. Measurements and analysis of stress in soil nails of CNC project[J]. Chinese Journal of Geotechnical Engineering，2010，32(Supp.2)：545–549.(in Chinese))
[41] 曹杰，肖明贵，徐小虎. 土钉墙支护结构土钉轴力计算方法分析[J]. 土工基础，2013，27(3)：80–82.(CAO Jie，XIAO Minggui，XU Xiaohu. Estimating of the axial nailing stress in soil nailed walls[J]. Soil Engineering and Foundation，2013，27(3)：80–82.(in Chinese))
[42] 张俊杰，刘泽. 动态施工条件下土钉内力计算方法研究[J]. 山西建筑，2014，39(2)：51–52.(ZHANG Junjie，LIU Ze. The research of internal calculation method of soil nailing force of dynamic construction conditions[J]. Shanxi Architecture，2014，39(2)：51–52.(in Chinese))
[43] 李盛青，叶志华，彭良泉. 基于动态施工的土钉支护力计算方法[J]. 人民长江，2005，36(2)：21–24.(LI Shengqing，YE Zhihua，PENG Liangquan. Calculation method of soil nailing support force based on dynamic construction[J]. Yangtze River，2005，36(2)：21–24.(in Chinese))
[44] 李成昌，肖明贵，卢林斌. 简化增量计算法在土钉支护基坑中的应用研究[J]. 路基工程，2009，26(5)：42–44.(LI Chengchang，XIAO Minggui，LU Linbin. Application of simplified incremental calculation method in soil nailing support of foundation pit[J]. Subgrade Engineering，2009，26(5)：42–44.(in Chinese))
[45] 丁振明. 土钉支护现场应力测试分析[J]. 工程勘察，2006，33(11)：65–67.(DING Zhenming. Field stress test and analysis of soil nailing support[J]. Journal of Geotechnical Investigation Surveying，2006，33(11)：65–67.(in Chinese))
[46] 郭志昆，杨惊东，马书广. 土钉内力的增量计算方法[J]. 解放军理工大学学报，2005，4(6)：355–358.(GUO Zhikun，YANG Jingdong，MA Shuguang. Incremental calculation method of soil nails internal force[J]. Journal of PLA University of Science and Technology，2005，4(6)：355–358.(in Chinese))
[47] 魏焕卫，宋丰波，杨敏，等. 基于明德林解的土钉内力计算方法[J]. 岩土工程，2011，32(4)：6–13.(WEI Huanwei，SONG Fengbo，YANG Ming，et al. Calculation method of inner force of soil nailing based on Mindlin solution[J]. Rock Soil Mechanics，2011，32(4)：6–13.(in Chinese))
[48] 郭红仙，宋二祥，陈肇元. 考虑施工过程的土钉支护土钉轴力计算及影响参数分析[J]. 土木工程学报，2007，20(11)：78–85.(GUO Hongxian，SONG Erxiang，CHEN Zhaoyuan. Analysis of the axial forces of soil nails during construction[J]. China Civil Engineering Journal，2007，20(11)：78–85.(in Chinese))
[49] 章昌保，高鹏飞，赵林，等. 规范法土钉轴力计算对比分析[J]. 内蒙古科技大学学报，2015，34(1)：91–95.(ZHANG Changbao，GAO Pengfei，ZHAO Lin，et al. Contrastive analysis of soil nail axial force with code method[J]. Journal of Inner Mongolia University of Science and Technology，2015，34(1)：91–95.(in Chinese))
[50] 张飞，刘忠臣，陈国刚. 预应力土层锚杆与土钉墙联合支护的力学工作机制研究[J]. 岩土力学，2002，23(3)：292–296.(ZHANG Fei，LIU Zongchen，CHEN Guogang. The mechanical working mechanism research on the united supporting of prestressed soil anchor and soil nailing[J]. Rock and Soil Mechanics，2002，23(3)：292–296.(in Chinese))
[51] 王曙光，段启伟，王艳永. 某土钉墙工程现场实测研究[J]. 建筑科学，2010，26(1)：90–92.(WANG Shuguang，DUAN Qiwei，WANG Yanyong. Research on the soil nail wall by field tests[J]. Build Science，2010，26(1)：90–92.(in Chinese))
[52] 王贵和，贾苍琴，季荣生，等. 深大基坑两级复合土钉支护现场测试研究[J]. 岩土力学，2008，29(10)：2 823–2 828.(WANG Guihe，JIA Cangqin，JI Rongsheng et al. Field testing study of deep and large foundation pit with two-step composite soil nailing[J]. Rock and Soil Mechanics，2008，29(10)：2 823–2 828.(in Chinese))
[53] 李斌. 北京国益大厦基坑土钉支护数值模拟与现场试验研究[硕士学位论文][D]. 北京：中国地质大学，2010.(LI Bin. Numerical simulation and field tests of Guoyi Building foundation pit support project in Beijing[M S. Thesis][D]. Beijing：China University of Geosciences，2010.(in Chinese))
[54] 刘合伍. 深基坑土钉支护工作机制数值模拟研究[硕士学位论文][D]. 广州：广东工业大学，2010.(LIU Hewu. Study on numerical simulation of working mechanism of soil nailing in deep foundation pit[M. S. Thesis][D]. Guangzhou：Guangdong University of Technology，2010.(in Chinese))
[55] 刘玲霞，姚海慧，李向全，等. 基于FLAC3D深基坑土钉支护结构内力分析[J]. 施工技术，2008，37(增)：85–89. (LIU Lingxia，YAO Haihui，LI Xiangquan，et al. FLAC3D analysis of internal forces of soil nails bracing construction in deep foundation pit[J]. Construction Technology，2008，37(Supp.)：85–89.(in Chinese))
[56] 唐业茂. 土钉墙支护基坑工程的监测与稳定性分析[J]. 廊坊师范学院学报：自然科学版，2014，14(4)：94–97.(TANG Yemao. The monitoring and stability analysis on soil nail wall supporting excavation engineering[J]. Journal of Langfang Teachers College：Natural Science，2014，14(4)：94–97.(in Chinese))
[57] 张百红，李国富，韩立军. 基坑土钉支护设计的简单算法研究[J]. 岩土力学，2008，29(11)：3 241–3 246.(ZHANG Baihong，LI Guofu，HAN Lijun. Research on simple calculating method of designing foundation pit supporting by soil nailing[J]. Rock and Soil Mechanics，2008，29(11)：3 241–3 246.(in Chinese))
[58] 吴忠诚，汤连生，廖志强，等. 深基坑复合土钉墙支护FLAC3D模拟及大型现场原位测试研究[J]. 岩土工程学报，2006，28(增)：1 460–1 465.(WU Zhongcheng，TANG Liansheng，LIAO Zhiqiang， et al. FLAC3D simulation of deep excavation with compound soil nailing support[J]. Chinese Journal of Geotechnical Engineering，2006，28(Supp.)：1 460–1 465.(in Chinese))
[59] 张国军. 深基坑土钉支护分析与优化设计研究[硕士学位论文][D]. 大连：大连理工大学，2002.(ZHANG Guojun. Studies on analysis and optimization design of soil nailing bracing in deep foundation pit[M. S. Thesis][D]. Dalian：Dalian University of Technology，2002.(in Chinese))
[60] 李铁军. 深基坑土钉支护实验研究及数值模拟[硕士学位论文][D]. 合肥：安徽理工大学，2009.(LI Tiejun. Research on field test of soil nailing and numerical simulation for deep excavation[M. S. Thesis][D]. Heifei：Anhui University of Science and Technology，2009.(in Chinese))
[61] PHOON K K，TANG C. Characterisation of geotechnical model uncertainty[J]. Georisk：Assessment Management of Risk for Engineered Systems Geohazards，2019，13(2)：101–130.
[62] ALLEN T M， BATHURST R J. Improved simplified method for prediction of loads in reinforced soil walls[J]. Journal of Geotechnical and Geoenvironmental Engineering，2015，141(11)：04015049.
[63] LIN P，BATHURST R J. Influence of cross correlation between nominal load and resistance on reliability-based design for simple linear soil-structure limit states[J]. Canadian Geotechnical Journal，2018，55(2)：279–295.