压缩空气硬岩储库关键问题研究进展：气密性能、热力过程与稳定性

doi:10.13722/j.cnki.jrme.2024.0030

Abstract
Figure/Table
References (0)
Related Citation (15)

Download: PDF (1272 KB) HTML (1 KB)
Export: BibTeX | EndNote (RIS)

Abstract Compressed air energy storage(CAES) is a kind of large-scale energy storage technology that is expected to be commercialized. As an underground gas storage engineering structure，the newly-excavated hard rock cavern has attracted much attentions due to its wide adaptability and practicability. Compared with traditional underground engineering，underground rock caverns for compressed air storage face many new challenges due to the periodic high internal pressure and temperature during the course of operation. Recently，great advances about the construction and operation of compressed air energy storage in hard rock caverns have been made by researchers around the world. It is thus imperative to systematically review the progress in this direction，which can help engineers to better understand the development of such emerging energy storage technology in practice. Firstly，the basic principles and scientific problems of compressed air energy storage are described. Secondly，the research progress related to construction and operation is summarized，including airtight performance of sealing structure，thermal transition process of surrounding rock-lining-sealing layer-air during the process of inflation and deflation，uplift failure of the rock mass，and plug stability. Besides，several key scientific and technological issues which need to be further studied are discussed.

Key words： rock mechanics compressed air energy storage airtight performance thermomechanical behavior stability

	Service

	E-mail this article
	Add to my bookshelf
	Add to citation manager
	E-mail Alert
	RSS
	Articles by authors
	ZHANG Guohua1
	2
	WANG Xinjin1
	XIANG Yue1
	PAN Jia1
	XIONG Feng1
	HUA Dongjie1
	TANG Zhicheng1

Cite this article:

ZHANG Guohua1,2,WANG Xinjin1, et al. Compressed air energy storage in hard rock caverns：airtight performance，thermomechanical behavior and stability[J]. , 2024, 43(11): 2601-2626.

URL:

https://rockmech.whrsm.ac.cn/EN/10.13722/j.cnki.jrme.2024.0030 OR https://rockmech.whrsm.ac.cn/EN/Y2024/V43/I11/2601

[1] 杨春和，王同涛. 深地储能研究进展[J]. 岩石力学与工程学报，2022，41(9)：1 729–1 759.(YANG Chunhe，WANG Tongtao. Advance in deep underground energy storage[J]. Chinese Journal of Rock Mechanics and Engineering，2022，41(9)：1 729–1 759.(in Chinese))
[2] 夏才初，周舒威，周瑜，等. 压缩空气储能的地下岩石内衬洞室关键技术[M]. 上海：同济大学出版社，2021：1–2.(XIA Caichu，ZHOU Shuwei，ZHOU Yu，et al. Key technologies for underground rock-lined cavern in compressed air energy storage：a comprehensive guide[M]. Shanghai：Tongji University Press，2021：1–2.(in Chinese))
[3] KUSHNIR R，ULLMANN A，DAYAN A. Thermodynamic and hydrodynamic response of compressed air energy storage reservoirs：a review[J]. Reviews in Chemical Engineering，2012，28(2/3)：123–148.
[4] LI Y，LI Y，LIU Y，et al. Compressed air energy storage in aquifers：basic principles，considerable factors and improvement approaches[J]. Reviews in Chemical Engineering，2021，37(5)：561–584.
[5] LI Y，LIU Y，HU B，et al. Potential influences of leakage through a high permeability path on shallow aquifers in compressed air energy storage in aquifers[J]. Renewable Energy，2023，209：661–676.
[6] HERBST H C，STYS Z S. Huntorf 290 MW-the world?s first Air Storage System Energy Transfer(ASSET) plant：construction and commissioning[C]// American Power Conference. Chicago，IL，USA：Proc. Am. Power Conf.，1978：40.
[7] GOODSON J O. History of first US compressed air energy storage (CAES) plant(110-MW-26 h)[R]. United States：Electric Power Research Inst.，Palo Alto，CA (United States)；Alabama Electric Cooperative，Andalusia，AL (United States). CAES Plant，1992.
[8] LUTYNSKI M. An overview of potential benefits and limitations of Compressed Air Energy Storage in abandoned coal mines[J]. IOP Conference Series：Materials Science and Engineering，2017，268：12 006.
[9] FAN J，LIU W，JIANG D，et al. Thermodynamic and applicability analysis of a hybrid CAES system using abandoned coal mine in China[J]. Energy，2018，157：31–44.
[10] MENÉNDEZ J，ORDÓÑEZ A，ÁLVAREZ R，et al. Energy from closed mines：Underground energy storage and geothermal applications[J]. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews，2019，108：498–512.
[11] ALLEN R D，DOHERTY T J，FOSSUM A F. Geotechnical issues and guidelines for storage of compressed air in excavated hard rock caverns[R]. Richland，Washington：Pacific Northwest National Lab.，1982.
[12] 中华人民共和国行业标准编写组. HJ 1258—1258核技术利用放射性废物库选址、设计与建造技术规范[S]. 北京：[s. n.]，2022.(The Professional Standards Compilation Group of People?s Republic of China. HJ 1258—1258 Technical specifications for siting，design and construction of radioactive waste repository for nuclear technology application[S]. Beijing：[s. n.]，2022.(in Chinese))
[13] 中国21世纪议程管理中心，中国地质调查局水文地质环境地质调查中心. 中国二氧化碳地质封存选址指南研究[M]. 北京：地质出版社，2012：1–269.(The Admi nistrarive Center For China?s Agenda 21，China Geological Survey. Guide for site screening of carbon dioxide terrestrial storage engineering[M]. Beijing：Geology Press，2012：1–269.(in Chinese))
[14] 祁生文，郑博文，王赞，等. 二氧化碳地质利用与封存场址的地质评价[J]. 中国科学：地球科学，2023，53(9)：1 937–1 957.(QI Shengwen，ZHENG Bowen，WANG Zan，et al. Geological evaluation for the carbon dioxide geological utilization and storage(CGUS) site：A review[J]. Science China Earth Sciences，2023，53(9)：1 937–    1 957.(in Chinese))
[15] DOHERTY T J，BECKWITH M A. Compressed air energy storage (caes) environmental and regulatory concerns[R]. Richland，Washington：Pacific Northwest National Laboratory，1982.
[16] DISTRICT N P P. NPPD seeks to add innovative energy solution to generation portfolio[EB/OL]. https：//www.nppd.com/press-releases/ nppd-seeks-to-add-innovative-energy-solution-to-generation-portfolio，2011–10–26/2023–12–1.
[17] FOSNACHT D R，WILSON E J，MARR J D，et al. Compressed air energy storage(CAES) in northern Minnesota using underground mine workings and above ground features[R]. Duluth，MN：University of Minnesota Duluth，2015.
[18] SUCCAR S S，WILLIAMS R H，CAVALLO A，et al. Compressed Air Energy Storage ：Theory，resources and applications for wind power[R]. Princeton：P.U. Princeton Environmental Institute，2008.
[19] FIRSTENERGY C. Firstenergy acquires rights to norton energy storage project[EB/OL]. www. firstenergycorp. com，2009–11–23/ 2023–12–1.
[20] 高木慎悟，西本吉伸. CAES—G/T圧縮空気空気地下貯蔵施設への気密シートの適用：気密材料の選定と原位置貯蔵試験結果[J]. ジオシンセティックス論文集，1999，14：308–317.(TAKAGI Shingo，NISHIMOTO Yoshinobu. Application of Sealing Sheet to CAES-G/T Compressed Air Underground Storage Facilities：Selection of Sealing Materials and In-Situ Storage Test Results[J]. Geosynthetics Journal，1999，14：308–317.(in Japanese))
[21] 沢田隆. 地下に空気を蓄めて発電する-CAES-G/T[J]. 電気学会誌，1996，116(11)：749–752.(SAWADA Takashi. Storing Air Underground for Power Generation-CAES-G/T[J]. The Journal of the Institute of Electrical Engineers of Japan，1996，116(11)：749–752.(in Japanese))
[22] 中田雅夫，山地宏志，中山昭彦，等. 圧縮空気エネルギー貯蔵に関わる熱力学的考察[J]. 土木学会論文集，1998，610：31–42.(NAKATA Masao，YAMACHI Hiroshi，NAKAYAMA Akihiko，et al. Thermo-dynamical approach to compressed air energy storage system[J]. Journal of the Japan Society of Civil Engineers，1998，1998(610)：31–42.(in Japanese))
[23] TERASHITA F，TAKAGI S，KOHJIYA S，et al. Airtight butyl rubber under high pressures in the storage tank of CAES—G/T system power plant[J]. Journal of Applied Polymer Science，2005，95(1)：173–177.
[24] 西本吉伸，高木慎悟，谷信三，等. 圧縮空気地下貯蔵発電(CAES-G/T)の圧縮空気貯蔵施設に適用する気密材の特性について[J]. 日本ゴム協会誌，2000，73(5)：225–232.(NISHIMOTO Yoshinobu，TAKAGI Shingo，TANAKA Mitsuba，et al. Application of air-tight sheet in the storage Tank for the Generation of electricity by the compressed air energy storage gas turbine system (CAES-G/T). -Selection of air-tight sheet and results of in-situ storage test.-[J]. Journal of the Japan Rubber Association，2000，73(5)：225–232.(in Japanese))
[25] 多田茂，吉田英生，越後亮三，等. CAES—G/T地下空洞の熱的挙動の数値予測：層流モデルと実験結果との比較[J]. 日本機械学会論文集B編，1998，64：3 830–3 837.(TADA Shigeru，YOSHIDA Hideo，ECHIGO Ryozo，et al. A numerical analysis of the air in a cavern for the CAWS-G/T (Laminar-model results compared with experiments)[J]. Transactions of the Japan Society of Mechanical Engineers，Part B，1998，64：3 830–3 837.(in Japanese))
[26] GLAMHEDEN R，CURTIS P. Excavation of a cavern for high-pressure storage of natural gas[J]. Tunnelling and Underground Space Technology，2006，21(1)：56–67.
[27] KIM H M，RUTQVIST J，RYU D W，et al. Exploring the concept of compressed air energy storage(CAES) in lined rock caverns at shallow depth：A modeling study of air tightness and energy balance[J]. Applied Energy，2012，92：653–667.
[28] RUTQVIST J，KIM H M，RYU D W，et al. Modeling of coupled thermodynamic and geomechanical performance of underground compressed air energy storage in lined rock caverns[J]. International Journal of Rock Mechanics and Mining Sciences，2012，52：71–81.
[29] KIM H M，RUTQVIST J，JEONG J H，et al. Characterizing excavation damaged zone and stability of pressurized lined rock caverns for underground compressed air energy storage[J]. Rock Mechanics and Rock Engineering，2013，46(5)：1 113–1 124.
[30] GEISSBÜHLER L，BECATTINI V，ZANGANEH G，et al. Pilot-scale demonstration of advanced adiabatic compressed air energy storage，Part 1：Plant description and tests with sensible thermal-energy storage[J]. Journal of Energy Storage，2018，17：129–139.
[31] BECATTINI V，GEISSBÜHLER L，ZANGANEH G，et al. Pilot-scale demonstration of advanced adiabatic compressed air energy storage，Part 2：Tests with combined sensible/latent thermal-energy storage[J]. Journal of Energy Storage，2018，17：140–152.
[32] RICAS. Public deliverables[EB/OL]. https：//www.ricas2020.eu/ research-areas/，2020/2023–12–1.
[33] MATOS C R，SILVA P P，CARNEIRO J F. Overview of compressed air energy storage projects and regulatory framework for energy storage[J]. Journal of Energy Storage，2022，55：105862.
[34] SYLVIA T，BELLINI E. New compressed air storage tech from Canada[EB/OL]. https：//www.pv-magazine.com/2021/04/16/new- compressed-air-storage-tech-from-canada/，2021–4–16/2023–12–1.
[35] AGENCY，A R E. Hydrostor Angas A-CAES Project[EB/OL]. https：// arena.gov.au/projects/hydrostor-angas-a-caes-project/，2021–2–19/ 2023–12–1.
[36] 蒋中明，李鹏，赵海斌，等. 压气储能浅埋地下储气库性能试验研究[J]. 岩土力学，2020，41(1)：235–241.(JIANG Zhongming，LI Peng，ZHAO Haibin，et al. Experimental study on performance of shallow rock cavern for compressed air energy storage[J]. Rock and Soil Mechanics，2020，41(1)：235–241.(in Chinese))
[37] XU Y J，ZHOU S W，XIA C C，et al. Three-dimensional thermo-mechanical analysis of abandoned mine drifts for underground compressed air energy storage：A comparative study of two construction and plugging schemes[J]. Journal of Energy Storage，2021，39：102696.
[38] 朝阳县人民政府. 中国能建集团朝阳市重点项目发布[EB/OL]. http：//www.cyx.gov.cn/html/CYXZF/202212/0167163081393353. html，2022–12–21/2023–12–1.(The People?s Government of Chaoyang County. Key Projects in Chaoyang City Released by China Energy Engineering Group Co.，Ltd[EB/OL]. http：//www.cyx.gov.cn/ html/CYXZF/202212/0167163081393353. html，2022–12–21/ 2023–12–1.(in Chinese))
[39] 中能建数字科技集团有限责任公司. 世界首台(套)300兆瓦人工硐室压缩空气储能电站开工[EB/OL]. http：//www.dtgc.ceec.net.cn/art/ 2022/12/21/art_58506_702.html，2022–12–21/2023–12–1.(China Energy Digital Technology Group CO.，Ltd. The world's first 300 MW artificial cavern compressed air energy storage power station has commenced construction[EB/OL]. http：//www.dtgc.ceec.net.cn/art/ 2022/12/21/art_58506_702.html，2022–12–21/2023–12–1.(in Chinese))
[40] 夏才初，张平阳，周舒威，等. 大规模压气储能洞室稳定性和洞周应变分析[J]. 岩土力学，2014，35(5)：1 391–1 398.(XIA Caichu，ZHANG Pingyang，ZHOU Shuwei，et al. Stability and tangential strain analysis of large-scale compressed air energy storage cavern[J]. Rock and Soil Mechanics，2014，35(5)：1 391–1 398.(in Chinese))
[41] 周瑜，夏才初，周舒威，等. 压气储能内衬洞室高分子密封层的气密与力学特性[J]. 岩石力学与工程学报，2018，37(12)：2 685– 2 696.(ZHOU Yu，XIA Caichu，ZHOU Shuwei，et al. Air tightness and mechanical characteristics of polymeric seals in lined rock caverns(LRCs) for compressed air energy storage(CAES)[J]. Chinese Journal of Rock Mechanics and Engineering，2018，37(12)：2 685– 2 696.(in Chinese))
[42] JIANG J，GUO P，YU X，et al. Stability of lower limit of air pressure in abandoned coal mine roadways during long-term CAES[J]. Frontiers in Ecology and Evolution，2023，11：1196749.
[43] 张国华，相月，王薪锦，等. 压气储能地下内衬储气库结构荷载分担解析解及影响因素分析[J]. 岩石力学与工程学报，2024，43(增2)：3 633–3 650.(ZHANG Guohua，XIANG Yue，WANG Xinjin，et al. Analytical Solution for Load Sharing in the Structure of an Underground Lined Rock Cavern for Compressed Air Energy Storage and Analysis of Influencing Factors[J]. Chinese Journal of Rock Mechanics and Engineering，2024，43(Supp.2)：3 633–3 650.(in Chinese))
[44] JOHANSSON J. Cavern wall design principles[M. S. Thesis][D]. Stockholm，Sweden：Royal Institute of Technology，2003.
[45] KIM H，LETTRY Y，PARK D，et al. Field evaluation of permeability of concrete linings and rock masses around underground lined rock caverns by a novel in-situ measurement system[J]. Engineering Geology，2012，137：97–106.
[46] ZHOU S W，XIA C C，ZHAO H B，et al. Numerical simulation for the coupled thermo-mechanical performance of a lined rock cavern for underground compressed air energy storage[J]. Journal of Geophysics and Engineering，2017，14(6)：1 382–1 398.
[47] JIANG Z M，LI P，TANG D，et al. Experimental and numerical investigations of small-scale lined rock cavern at shallow depth for compressed air energy storage[J]. Rock Mechanics and Rock Engineering，2020，53(6)：2 671–2 683.
[48] dE PRADO L A，MENÉNDEZ J，BERNARDO-SÁNCHEZ A，et al. Thermodynamic analysis of compressed air energy storage(CAES) reservoirs in abandoned mines using different sealing layers[J]. Applied Sciences-Basel，2021，11(6)：2 573.
[49] 蒋中明，黄毓成，刘澜婷，等. 平江浅埋地下储气实验库力学响应数值分析[J]. 水利水电科技进展，2019，39(6)：37–43.(JIANG Zhongming，HUANG Yucheng，LIU Lanting，et al. Numerical analysis of mechanical response of Pingjiang shallow underground pilot cavern for compressed air storage[J]. Advances in Science and Technology of Water Resources，2019，39(6)：37–43.(in Chinese))
[50] CHENG Z，YE B，NI X，et al. Exploration of factors reducing the effect of heating/cooling cycles on the gas permeability of a mortar[J]. Journal of Materials in Civil Engineering，2019，31(11)：4019251.
[51] RAJAK D K，PAGAR D D，MENEZES P L，et al. Fiber-reinforced polymer composites：manufacturing，properties，and applications[J]. Polymers，2019，11(10)：1 667.
[52] NISHIMOTO Y，TAKAGI S，KOHJIYA S，et al. Performance and characteristics of air-tight sealing material used in CAES—G/T air storage cavern[J]. Journal-Society of Rubber Industry Japan，2000，73(5)：225–232.
[53] 中华人民共和国行业标准编写组. GB/T 1038.1—1038.1 塑料制品薄膜和薄片气体透过性试验方法第1部分：差压法[S]. 北京：中国标准出版社，2022.(The Professional Standards Compilation Group of People?s Republic of China. GB/T 1038.1—1038.1 Plastics-film and sheeting- determination of gas-transmission rate Part 1：Differential-pressure methods[S]. Beijing：Standards Press of China，2022.(in Chinese))
[54] ASTM International. D1434-82 Standard test method for determining gas permeability characteristics of plastic film and sheeting[S]. Pennsylvania：West Conshohocken，2003.
[55] GORBACHEV B N，NIKIFOROV N N，CHEBANOV V M. Air permeability of polymers subjected to high pressures[J]. Polymer Mechanics，1976，12(6)：969–972.
[56] CAMPION R，MORGAN G，SAMULAK M. Some durability aspects of thermoplastics for oilfield flexible pipes[J]. Polymers and Polymer Composites，1997，5(6)：451–458.
[57] NAKATA M，YAMACHI H，HAYASHI T，et al. Experimental study on the tightness of lining systems for pressurized gas storage[J]. Doboku Gakkai Ronbunshu，1998，1998：21–35.
[58] BRISCOE B J，GRITSIS D，LIATSIS D. The concentration and pressure dependent diffusion of carbon dioxide in nitrile rubbers[J]. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London. Series A：Physical and Engineering Sciences，1992，339：497–519.
[59] KELLER J U，RAVE H，STAUDT R. Measurement of gas absorption in a swelling polymeric material by a combined gravimetric-dynamic method[J]. Macromolecular Chemistry and Physics，1999，200(10)：2 269–2 275.
[60] DAVIS P K，LUNDY G D，PALAMARA J E，et al. New pressure-decay techniques to study gas sorption and diffusion in polymers at elevated pressures[J]. Industrial and Engineering Chemistry Research，2004，43(6)：1 537–1 542.
[61] WIFF D R，ROACH J F. Direct measurement of permeabilities at high pressures[J]. Polymer Engineering and Science，2001，41(12)：      2 200–2 205.
[62] FLACONNÈCHE B，MARTIN J M，KLOPFFER M H. Transport properties of gases in polymers：experimental methods[J]. Oil and Gas Science and Technology-revue De L Institut Francais Du Petrole，2001，56：245–259.
[63] ADEWOLE J K，JENSEN L，AL-MUBAIYEDH U A，et al. Transport properties of natural gas through polyethylene nanocomposites at high temperature and pressure[J]. Journal of Polymer Research，2012，19(2)：9 814.
[64] PEREZ E，BALKUS K，FERRARIS J，et al. Instrument for gas permeation measurements at high pressure and high temperature[J]. The Review of scientific instruments，2013，84：65107.
[65] 夏才初，秦世康，赵海鸥，等. 循环热力作用下压气储能洞室钢衬的疲劳耐久性[J]. 同济大学学报：自然科学版，2023，51(10)：     1 564–1 573.(XIA Caichu，QIN Shikang，ZHAO Haiou，et al. Fatigue durability of steel lining in compressed air energy storage caverns under cyclic thermo-mechanical effects[J]. Journal of Tongji University：Natural Science，2023，51(10)：1 564–1 573.(in Chinese))
[66] ÅBERG B. Prevention of gas leakage from unlined reservoirs in rock[C]// MAGNUS BERGMAN. Proceedings of the First International Symposium，Storage in Excavated Rock Caverns：Rockstore 77. Stockholm：Elsevier Science Publishers，1978：399–413.
[67] GIRAMONTI A J，LESSARD R D，BLECHER W A，et al. Conceptual design of compressed air energy storage electric power systems[J]. Applied Energy，1978，4(4)：231–249.
[68] GIRAMONTI A J. Preliminary feasibility evaluation of compressed air storage power systems[R]. East Hartford，CT(USA)：United Technologies Research Center，1976.
[69] ALLEN R D，DOHERTY T J，THOMS R L. Geotechnical factors and guidelines for storage of compressed air in solution-mined salt cavities[R]. Richland，Washington：Pacific Northwest National Lab，1982.
[70] ALLEN R D，DOHERTY T J，ERIKSON R L，et al. Factors affecting storage of compressed air in porous-rock reservoirs[R]. Richland，Washington：Pacific Northwest National Lab，1983.
[71] ALLEN K. CAES：The underground portion[J]. IEEE Transactions on Power Apparatus and Systems，1985，PAS–104(4)：809–812.
[72] 万发，蒋中明，廖峻慧，等. 地下水对CAES地下储气库气密性和围岩稳定性影响[J]. 岩土工程学报，2024，46(9)：1 899–1 908. (WAN Fa，JIANG Zhongming，LIAO Junhui，et al. Study on the influence of groundwater on air tightness and surrounding rock stability of CAES underground gas storage[J]. Chinese Journal of Geotechnical Engineering，2024，46(9)：1 899–1 908.(in Chinese))
[73] SALTER M D G，MACFARLANE I M，WILLETT D C，et al. 5 Design aspects for an underground compressed air energy storage system in hard rock[C]// Design and Performance of Underground Excavations：ISRM Symposium. Cambridge，U.K：Thomas Telford Publishing，1984：37–44.
[74] HAYASHI M. Rock mechanics of compressed air energy storage and super magnetic energy storage in Japan[J]. Rock Mechanics in Japan，1991，6：50–57.
[75] ISHIHATA T. Underground compressed air storage facility for CAES-G/T power plant utilizing an airtight lining[J]. International Society for Rock Mechanics，1997，5(1)：17–21.
[76] HORI M，GODA Y，ONISHI H. Mechanical behaviour of surrounding rock mass and new lining structure of air-tight pressure cavern[C]// 10th ISRM Congress. ISRM，2003：ISRM-10CONGRESS.
[77] KIM H M，LETTRY Y，RYU D W，et al. Mock-up experiments on permeability measurement of concrete and construction joints for air tightness assessment[J]. Materials and Structures. 2014，47(1/2)：127–140.
[78] KIM H M，PARK D，RYU D W，et al. Parametric sensitivity analysis of ground uplift above pressurized underground rock caverns[J]. Engineering Geology，2012，135：60–65.
[79] KIM，H.-M.，J. RUTQVIST，B.-H. Choi. Feasibility analysis of underground compressed air energy storage in lined rock caverns using the TOUGH-FLAC simulator[C]// TOUGH Symposium 2012. Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory，Berkeley，California：2012.
[80] ALLEN R D，DOHERTY T J，KANNBERG L D. Summary of selected compressed air energy storage studies[R]. Richland，Washington：Pacific Northwest National Lab，1985.
[81] GOODALL D C. Containment of gas in rock caverns[Ph. D. Thesis][D]. United States：University of California，Berkeley，CA，1987.
[82] GOODALL D C，ÅBERG B，BREKKE T L. Fundamentals of gas containment in unlined rock caverns[J]. Rock Mechanics and Rock Engineering，1988，21(4)：235–258.
[83] DAVIES P B. Evaluation of the role of threshold pressure in controlling flow of waste-generated gas into bedded salt at the Waste Isolation Pilot Plant[M]. Albuquerque，NM：Sandia National Laboratories，1991.
[84] LIANG J，LINDBLOM U. Analyses of gas-storage capacity in unlined rock caverns[J]. Rock Mechanics and Rock Engineering，1994，27(3)：115–134.
[85] RA S H，SUNG W M. An analysis of gas tightness around unlined storage cavern using a discrete fracture flow FEM model[J]. Geosystem Engineering，1999，2(2)：61–67.
[86] PRUESS K. A General purpose numerical simulator for multiphase fluid and heat[R]. Berkeley，California：Lawrence Berkeley Laboratory，University of California，1991.
[87] 李宏，里优，河原裕德，等. 三维有限元多相流程序的开发及其在地下压缩空气电力储藏和二氧化碳煤层固定中的应用[J]. 岩石力学与工程学报，2003，22(增1)：2 371–2 377.(LI Hong，Masaru Sato，Hironori Kawahara，et al. Development of 3D finite element multi-phase flow program for compressed air energy storage and co2 sequestration in coal seam[J]. Chinese Journal of Rock Mechanics and Engineering，2003，22(Supp.1)：2 371–2 377.(in Chinese))
[88] BAUER S J，GAITHER K N，WEBB S W，et al. Compressed air energy storage in hard rock feasibility study[J]. Sandia National Laboratories，SAND2012-0540，Albuquerque，NM，2012.
[89] KAWATANI T，SAITO M. Two-phase flow simulation of water scaling of compressed air storage under cyclic pressure change in an unlined rock cavern[C]// ModelCARE 1999 Conference. Zurich，Switzerland：[s. n.]，1999：432–438.
[90] 叶斌，程子睿，彭益成. 压气储能洞室气密性影响因素分析[J]. 同济大学学报：自然科学版，2016，44(10)：1 526–1 532.(YE Bin，CHENG Zirui，PENG Yicheng. Analysis of influence factors on air tightness of underground cavern for compressed air energy storage[J]. Journal of Tongji University：Natural Science，2016，44(10)：1 526– 1 532.(in Chinese))
[91] 夏才初，徐英俊，王辰霖，等. 基于非稳态渗流过程的压气储能洞室空气渗漏率计算[J]. 岩土力学，2021，42(7)：1 765–1 773.(XIA Caichu，XU Yingjun，WANG Chenlin，et al. Calculation of air leakage rate in lined cavern for compressed air energy storage based on unsteady seepage process[J]. Rock and Soil Mechanics，2021，42(7)：1 765–1 773.(in Chinese))
[92] 周瑜，夏才初，赵海斌，等. 压气储能内衬洞室的空气泄漏率及围岩力学响应估算方法[J]. 岩石力学与工程学报，2017，36(2)：297–309.(ZHOU Yu，XIA Caichu，ZHAO Haibin，et al. A method for estimating air leakage through inner seals and mechanical responses of the surrounding rock of lined rock caverns for compressed air energy storage[J]. Chinese Journal of Rock Mechanics and Engineering，2017，36(2)：297–309.(in Chinese))
[93] 周瑜. 压气储能内衬洞室密封结构的密封性及耐久性研究[博士学位论文][D]. 上海：同济大学，2017.(ZHOU Yu. Study on sealing and durability of sealing structure of compressed air energy storage lining cavern[Ph. D. Thesis][D]. Shanghai：Tongji University，2017.(in Chinese))
[94] XIA C C，ZHOU Y，ZHOU S W，et al. A simplified and unified analytical solution for temperature and pressure variations in compressed air energy storage caverns[J]. Renewable Energy，2015，74：718–726.
[95] WU D，WANG J G，HU B W，et al. A coupled thermo-hydro- mechanical model for evaluating air leakage from an unlined compressed air energy storage cavern[J]. Renewable Energy，2020，146：907–920.
[96] QIN S K，XIA C C，ZHOU S W. Air tightness of compressed air storage energy caverns with polymer sealing layer subjected to various air pressures[J]. Journal of Rock Mechanics and Geotechnical Engineering，2023，15(8)：2 105–2 116.
[97] WANG C L，LI G D，YU Z B，et al. Stability and sealing of abandoned roadways under high internal pressure[J]. Mining Metallurgy and Exploration，2023，40(3)：871–884.
[98] KUSHNIR R，ULLMANN A，DAYAN A. Thermodynamic models for the temperature and pressure variations within adiabatic caverns of compressed air energy storage plants[J]. Journal of Energy Resources Technology-Transactions of the Asme，2012，134(2)：21901.
[99] OSTERLE J F. The thermodynamics of compressed-air exergy storage[J]. Journal of Energy Resources Technology-Transactions of the Asme，1991，113(1)：7–11.
[100] SKOREK J，BANASIK K. Thermodynamics analysis of the compressed-air energy storage systems operation[J]. Inzynieria Chemiczna I Procesowa，2006：187–200.
[101] ZHANG Y，YANG K，LI X M，et al. The thermodynamic effect of air storage chamber model on Advanced Adiabatic Compressed Air Energy Storage System[J]. Renewable Energy，2013，57：469–478.
[102] LANGHAM E J. The underground storage of compressed air for gas turbines：a dynamic study on an analogue computer[J]. The Computer Journal，1965，8：216–224.
[103] VOSBURGH K G，KOSKY P G. Heat transfer effects in compressed air energy storage[C]// Heat Transfer in Energy Conservation；Proceedings of the Winter Annual Meeting. Atlanta，Ga：American Society of Mechanical Engineers，1977：83–90.
[104] YOSHIDA H，TADA S，OISHI Y，et al. Thermo-fluid behavior in the cavern for the compressed air energy storage gas turbine system[C]// 11th International Heat Transfer Conference. Kyongju，South Korea：[s. n.]，1998：523–528.
[105] RAJU M，KHAITAN S K. Modeling and simulation of compressed air storage in caverns：A case study of the Huntorf plant[J]. Applied Energy，2012，89(1)：474–481.
[106] KUSHNIR R，DAYAN A，ULLMANN A. Temperature and pressure variations within compressed air energy storage caverns[J]. International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer，2012，55(21/22)：    5 616–5 630.
[107] ZHOU Y，XIA C C，ZHAO H B，et al. An iterative method for evaluating air leakage from unlined compressed air energy storage (CAES) caverns[J]. Renewable Energy，2018，120：434–445.
[108] PERAZZELLI P，ANAGNOSTOU G. Design issues for compressed air energy storage in sealed underground cavities[J]. Journal of Rock Mechanics and Geotechnical Engineering，2016，8(3)：314–328.
[109] 蒋中明，秦双专，栋唐. 压气储能地下储气库围岩累积损伤特性数值研究[J]. 岩土工程学报，2020，42(2)：230–238.(JIANG Zhongming，QIN Shuangzhuan，TANG Dong. Numerical study on accumulative damage characteristics of underground rock caverns for compressed air energy storage[J]. Chinese Journal of Geotechnical Engineering，2020，42(2)：230–238.(in Chinese))
[110] 周舒威，夏才初，张平阳，等. 地下压气储能圆形内衬洞室内压和温度引起应力计算[J]. 岩土工程学报，2014，36(11)：2 025–2 035. (ZHOU Shuwei，XIA Caichu，ZHANG Pingyang，et al. Analytical approach for stress induced by internal pressure and temperature of underground compressed air energy storage in a circular lined rock cavern[J]. Chinese Journal of Geotechnical Engineering，2014，36(11)：2 025–2 035.(in Chinese))
[111] 蒋中明，李小刚，万发，等. 压气储能遂昌地下储气库结构应力变形特性数值研究[J]. 长沙理工大学学报：自然科学版，2021，18(3)：79–86.(JIANG Zhongming，LI Xiaogang，WAN Fa，et al. Numerical study on stress and deformation characteristics of structure of underground gas storage for CAES in Suichang[J]. Journal of Changsha University of Science and Technology：Natural Science，2021，18(3)：79–86.(in Chinese))
[112] JONGPRADIST P，TUNSAKUL J，KONGKITKUL W，et al. High internal pressure induced fracture patterns in rock masses surrounding caverns：Experimental study using physical model tests[J]. Engineering Geology，2015，197：158–171.
[113] PERAZZELLI P，ANAGNOSTOU G，AMBERG J. Uplift analysis for CAES tunnels[C]// Computer Methods and Recent Advances in Geomechanics：Proceedings of the 14th International Conference of International Association for Computer Methods and Recent Advances in Geomechanics，2014. Leiden：Taylor and Francis Books Ltd，2015：1 691–1 696.
[114] CARRANZA-TORRES C，FOSNACHT D，HUDAK G. Geomechanical analysis of the stability conditions of shallow cavities for Compressed Air Energy Storage(CAES) applications[J]. Geomechanics and Geophysics for Geo-energy and Geo-resources，2017，3(2)：131–174.
[115] 孙冠华，王章星，王娇，等. 压缩空气储能电站地下硐库安全埋深计算的极限平衡方法[J]. 土木工程学报，2023，56(增2)：67–77. (SUN Guanhua，WANG Zhangxing，WANG Jiao，et al. Limit equilibrium method for calculating the safe burialdepth of underground caverns in compressed air energy storage[J]. China Civil Engineering Journal，2023，56(Supp.2)：67–77.(in Chinese))
[116] 孙冠华，易琪，姚院峰，等. 压缩空气储能电站隧道式地下硐库潜在失稳模式研究[J]. 岩石力学与工程学报，2024，43(1)：41–49. (SUN Guanhua，YI Qi，YAO Yuanfeng，et al. Study on the potential instability patterns of high pressurized air storage tunnels for compressed air energy storage[J]. Chinese Journal of Rock Mechanics and Engineering，2024，43(1)：41–49.(in Chinese))
[117] 徐英俊，夏才初，周舒威，等. 基于极限分析上限定理的压气储能洞室抗隆起破坏准则[J]. 岩石力学与工程学报，2022，41(10)：    1 971–1 980.(XU Yingjun，XIA Caichu，ZHOU Shuwei，et al. Anti-uplift failure criterion of caverns for compressed air energy storage based on the upper bound theorem of limit analysis[J]. Chinese Journal of Rock Mechanics and Engineering，2022，41(10)：1 971– 1 980.(in Chinese))
[118] 王者超，贾文杰，冯夏庭，等. 隧洞式内衬储气库极限储存压力解析解[J]. 力学学报，2023，55(3)：710–718.(WANG Zhechao，JIA Wenjie，FENG Xiating，et al. Analytical solution of limit storage pressures for tunnel type lined gas storage caverns1[J]. Chinese Journal of Theoretical and Applied Mechanics，2023，55(3)：710–718.(in Chinese))
[119] AULD F A. Design of underground plugs[J]. International Journal of Mining Engineering，1983，1(3)：189–228.
[120] GARRETT W S，Campbell-Pitt L. Design and construction of underground water seals and water barriers[C]// Proceedings of Seventh Commonwealth mining and Metallurgical Conference. Johannesburg：South African Institute of Mining and Metallurgy，1961：1 283–1 301.
[121] KALMYKOV E P. Methodology to compute underground water impermeable dams[J]. Ugol，1968，(9)：43–51.
[122] GUPTA R N，MUKHERJEE K P，SINGH B. Design of underground artificial dams for mine water storage[J]. International Journal of Mine Water，1987，6(2)：1–14.
[123] PORATHUR J L，JOSE M，BHATTACHARJEE R，et al. Numerical modeling approach for design of water-retaining dams in underground hard rock minesa case example[J]. Arabian Journal of Geosciences，2018，11(23)：750.
[124] 伊藤雄三，山口順之. 新しい電力負荷平準化システム圧縮空気貯蔵ガスタービン発電(CAES-G/T)パイロットプラントの見学[J]. 電気学会誌，2001，4：234–237.(YUZOU Ito, JUNNOSUKE Yamaguchi. Tour of the New Power Load Equalization System Compressed Air Energy Storage Gas Turbine Power Generation (CAES-G/T) Pilot Plant[J]. The Institute of Electrical Engineers of Japan Journal，2001，4：234–237.(in Japanese))
[125] PEDRETTI A，VIETTI D，PEDRAZZINI M B，et al. Reuse of abandoned underground structures - the compressed air energy storage test plant in Switzerland[C]// World Tunnel Congress(WTC)/39th General Assembly of the International-Tunnelling-and-Underground- Space-Association(ITA). London：[s. n.]，2013：35–42.
[126] OKUNO T，WAKABAYASHI N，NIIMI K，et al. Advanced natural gas storage system and verification tests of lined rock cavern-ANGAS project in Japan[J]. International Journal of the JCRM，2009，2(5)：95–102.
[127] PARK D，KIM H，RYU D，et al. Numerical study on the optimal shape of concrete plug for compressed air energy storage caverns[J]. Journal of Korean Society for Rock Mechanics，2011，21(3)：164–173.
[128] SONG W K，RYU D W，LEE Y K. Stability analysis of concrete plugs in a pilot cavern for compressed air energy storage[C]// The 12th ISRM International Congress on Rock Mechanics. Beijing：[s. n.]，2012：1 813–1 816.
[129] USMANI A，KANNAN G，NANDA A，et al. Analysis and design approach for concrete plugs for underground storage caverns[J]. Practice Periodical on Structural Design and Construction，2016，21(1)：4015004.